Daily Alert Archives

Is an Israel-U.S. Defense Pact in Israel's Best Interests?

(Jerusalem Post) Editorial - The idea of a U.S.-Israel mutual defense treaty is enjoying a renaissance. Although the idea of a defense pact that would obligate the U.S. to come to Israel's defense in case of an existential threat is enticing, it is something Jerusalem needs to consider very carefully because, along with the advantages, there are also drawbacks. The most obvious benefit is its message to Iran and other enemies of Israel. If such a treaty is ratified by a Senate supermajority, it locks U.S. commitments into a permanent framework. However, such a treaty could potentially reduce Israel's freedom of action and mean that Israel would need U.S. permission to act militarily. Paradoxically, a deal intended to deter Israel's enemies could actually diminish deterrence by tying Israel's hands, particularly when it comes to Iran. Moreover, a mutual defense pact might potentially draw Israel into conflicts that would imperil its relations with other countries and undermine other Israeli interests. Finally, such a pact conflicts with the key Zionist principle of self-reliance. Would such a pact be so superior to the current understandings with the U.S.?
2023-09-26 00:00:00
Full Article