|
Trending Topics
|
I Was in the Room when Israel Decided to Kill Nasrallah. Here's Why We Had to Do It
(Jewish Chronicle-UK) Or Horvitz - Two years ago, I sat in a room where the question being discussed was: Should Israel strike Hassan Nasrallah, a man I had spent much of my professional life studying? Hundreds of intelligence officers and analysts spent years building the intelligence case for targeting Nasrallah and minimizing harm to civilians. I remember Col. M., who led intelligence work on Hizbullah, when she told us: "We have it. If you decide to act, you can." What remained was the strategic decision. In the room, not one person objected. Mindful of the lessons of Oct. 7, we sought dissenting views and contacted two people considered most likely to oppose the operation. Both supported it. Nasrallah blocked any ceasefire in Lebanon and would never unlink the Lebanese front from Gaza. I watched the live images as the bombs hit the compound where he was staying. When confirmation arrived, I felt profound relief and satisfaction that a man whose organization had killed so many Israelis and Americans was gone. Nasrallah led Hizbullah from 1992 and transformed it into a force that served Iran far beyond its borders. Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon in 2000 allowed Hizbullah to claim that armed resistance had forced the Israeli military out. The 2006 Lebanon War, which Nasrallah cast as a divine victory despite the devastation in Lebanon, made him a star across much of the Arab and Islamic worlds. Afterward, Hizbullah amassed an arsenal and precision-strike capabilities that gave it firepower rivaling that of many states, deterring Israel for years from taking decisive action against it. Yet, decades in power dulled Nasrallah's instincts and bred an arrogance that distorted his judgment. Nasrallah came to believe that no one understood Israel and the Jews better than he did, and that Iran's Shiite revolutionary project was destined to triumph. Nasrallah's killing marked a decisive turning point in Hizbullah's decline. It still exists and remains dangerous, but it is a pale shadow of the force that once possessed the capabilities of a state military and threatened Israel, American lives, and the stability of the Middle East. The writer, former head of the Israel Defense Intelligence Hizbullah branch, is a fellow at the Jewish People Policy Institute (JPPI).