Current Edition About Subscribe The Jerusalem Center

Daily Alert Archive

Every Daily Alert Since 2002

Search

Search more than 90,000 news items by topic, author, or source.
Use " " to search for multiple words and phrases.

Trending Topics

October 22, 2026       Share:    

Source: https://www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/israels-lobby-review-the-revival-of-an-old-smear-15333a45?mod=opinion_feat1_reviews_pos5

Review: Revival of the Old "Israel's Lobby" Smear

(Wall Street Journal) Daniel J. Samet - The notion that the pro-Israel lobby pulls the strings has long been popular among conspiracists. In 2007, John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt published The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, which gave a weak argument the veneer of scholarship. Two decades later, Eli Clifton and Ian Lustick pick up where they left off in Israel's Lobby: America in the Grip of a Foreign Power. Their assertions quickly unravel. Take one: Israel has used its relationship with the U.S. "to extract unconditional aid, coordination, and support at a scale and for a duration beyond anything a great power has ever done for a foreign country." But there are numerous examples of great powers doing more for foreign countries than America has ever done for Israel. Britain lost nearly a million men defending France and Belgium in World War I. The U.S. has kept tens of thousands of troops in Japan since 1945 and in South Korea since 1950, before Israel received any American military aid. The authors state that Israel has "consistently bent American policy to its will." It is the other way around. From Dwight Eisenhower's pushing Israel out of Egypt during the Suez Crisis to Joe Biden's forcing Israel into a ceasefire with Hamas in 2021, the U.S. has repeatedly made Israel veer from its preferred course. The authors claim the Israel lobby has been behind Congressional opposition to Barack Obama's Iran deal. The thought that lawmakers opposed Obama's nuclear deal because they believed it deleterious to U.S. interests doesn't occur to them. The authors refer to "the ongoing genocide in Gaza" and paint a picture of a rogue, illiberal Israel running roughshod over the Middle East. In fact, Israel's Arab population has skyrocketed since 1948 and now numbers more than two million, while the Jewish population in the rest of the Middle East has shrunk to near zero. Israel has never seen a day without enemies bent on destroying it, but the authors won't acknowledge the little country's enormous security concerns. The writer is a Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

View the full edition of Daily Alert

Back to Archive

Subscribe to Daily Alert: