Current Edition About Subscribe The Jerusalem Center

Daily Alert Archive

Every Daily Alert Since 2002

Search

Search more than 90,000 news items by topic, author, or source.
Use " " to search for multiple words and phrases.

Trending Topics

November 12, 2026       Share:    

Source: https://ideas.tikvah.org/mosaic/essays/responses/americans-need-to-worry-about-islamist-ideology-not-muslim-demographics

Americans Need to Worry about Islamist Ideology, Not Muslim Demographics

(Mosaic) Dalia Ziada - As candidates with possible ties to the Muslim Brotherhood achieved unprecedented electoral victories in the U.S. midterm elections, some commentators have attributed the threat posed by Islamism to American Muslims as a whole. When critics treat Muslim communities as a monolithic Islamist constituency, they inadvertently reinforce this narrative and further empower Islamists. Thus, differentiating Islam from Islamism is a strategic imperative. An increase in the Muslim population does not inherently result in a larger Islamist constituency, just as the expansion of Islamist political movements does not necessarily depend on demographic growth among Muslims. Most American Muslims reject terrorism and violent jihad, yet a significant minority holds views incompatible with liberal democracy. However, Muslims cannot be regarded as a homogeneous political constituency with uniform beliefs and aspirations. If anything, American Muslims who oppose political Islam are potential allies. Islamist ideology poses a real threat to American democracy and there is a need for serious scrutiny of antisemitism within Muslim communities. To address these threats, it is necessary to reckon with the capacity of Islamist movements and their political narratives to gain acceptance among groups with no religious affiliation with Islam. The relationship between Islamist movements and segments of the Western radical left is particularly significant in this context. Resistance to Western political dominance, American foreign policy, capitalism, and Israel has created opportunities for cooperation among actors whose ideological bases differ significantly. In the Michigan Senate election, Abdul El-Sayed received 2.5 million votes, while Michigan's Muslim population is estimated at 274,000. Therefore, at least 89% of his electoral support must have come from non-Muslims. In Zohran Mamdani's victory in New York City's 2025 mayoral election, he received nearly 51% of the vote, while Muslims were estimated to constitute 7% of the registered voters. Islamism should be understood as a political ideology rather than a religion. It is possible for individuals to identify as Muslim while rejecting political Islamism, as demonstrated by many in Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Bahrain (all Arab Muslim-majority countries), where the Muslim Brotherhood has been banned or restricted. Conversely, non-Muslims may support political Islam. The critical question is: how do political ideas associated with Islamist movements, often focused on undermining Western civilization from within, gain legitimacy and support among non-Muslim Americans, particularly within progressive political circles? Addressing this question, rather than locating the problem with Muslims collectively, may facilitate a more accurate diagnosis of the political threats currently facing the U.S. This should be the starting point for a rigorous examination of the Islamist challenge to American democracy. The writer, an Egyptian scholar, is a Senior Fellow at the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs.

View the full edition of Daily Alert

Back to Archive

Subscribe to Daily Alert: