|
Trending Topics
|
Source: https://www.jpost.com/opinion/article-914597
El-Sayed's Victory Exposes a Growing Divide between Israelis and American Jews
(Jerusalem Post) Dr. Irwin J. Mansdorf - Abdul El-Sayed's victory in Michigan's U.S. Senate race should raise uncomfortable questions for Israelis. A politician who opposed American military assistance to Israel won support from segments of American Jewry as progressive identity increasingly shapes political choices, often taking precedence over traditional solidarity with Israel. For Israelis, Jewish identity is inseparable from sovereignty, national self-determination, and physical security. Threats from Iran, Hamas, and Hizbullah are everyday realities. A strong Jewish state represents the ultimate guarantee against the vulnerability that defined centuries of Jewish history. For progressive Jewish Americans, however, Jewish identity often translates into a different political commitment. Healthcare, education, climate change, minority rights, and opposition to President Trump and the Republican Party form their moral center of gravity. Israel is judged through this ideological lens, and support becomes conditional upon its adherence to progressive expectations. Israelis overwhelmingly understand Zionism as the Jewish people's legitimate movement for national self-determination. Parts of the American progressive Left, however, increasingly interpret the conflict through an oppressor-versus-oppressed framework. Israel becomes the powerful oppressor, while Palestinians are incorporated into a broader narrative of systemic injustice. The willingness of some Jewish progressives to support candidates sharply critical of Israel reflects a cultural shift that Israelis can no longer ignore. For a growing segment of American Jewry, Israel is becoming less an indispensable expression of Jewish identity and more a moral liability. The writer is a clinical psychologist and a fellow at the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, specializing in political psychology.